2. Obama Denies Keystone XL Pipeline Permit
Four years ago, most of Washington, D.C.’s “energy insiders” agreed that the proposed Keystone XL tar sands pipeline was a done deal. I’m embarrassed to say that, at the time, I agreed, and wrote a callow editorial pointing out what seemed to me the strategic flaws in the Keystone campaign.
Though I eventually came around, I’ll admit to being short-sighted, and I’m thrilled that the optimists proved the haters wrong.
Several massive grassroots mobilizations and hundreds of smaller rallies later, the fight over Keystone XL had become the environmental movement’s signature battle. In the end, greens won: In November, President Obama announced that he would not approve the pipeline.
The path to victory was in many ways as important as the victory itself. Throughout the Keystone XL campaign, green groups were more aggressive and visible than they had been in years. In August 2011, 350.org and allies staged the largest show of environmental civil disobedience since the height of the anti-nuclear movement, leading to more than a thousand arrests at the White House. In the fall of 2011, thousands of people encircled the White House. In 2013, greens organized the muscular Forward on Climate Rally and staged more White House arrests, including the Sierra Club’s first foray into civil disobedience in its history. In 2014, the strange bedfellows of the Cowboys and Indian Alliance set up camp on the National Mall. Along the way, Keystone XL became a political football and (though my bosses hate to hear me say this) a political symbol: a clear choice between continuing on our carbonated kamikaze mission, or making a sharp turn toward the clean energy future. The long-running Keystone XL fight revealed an American environmental movement no longer willing to play it safe and eager to buck the conventional wisdom.
Cynics still quibble that even as Keystone became a cause celebre, hundreds of other oil and gas pipelines were constructed. True. And, at the same time, many of those faced stiff local and regional and even national opposition. That’s why the Keystone XL will victory will matter for years to come. Fossil fuel infrastructure projects are no longer inevitable; at the very least they won’t go forward without a fight. Whether it’s an oil refinery expansion, a proposed coal port, increased crude-by-rail shipments, or coal leases on public lands, there will be no more done deals.
Photo by J. Sierra/Sierra Club