February 9, 2021
by Caitlin Ferrante, Chapter Staff & Gale Pisha, Lower Hudson Group
Each year, it seems like there’s a new carcinogenic chemical we’re reading about, an alphabet soup of toxicity to add to our list of concerns — BPA (bisphenol A) in our plastic bottles and receipt paper, TCE (trichloroethylene) leaking into our drinking water, 1,4-dioxane in many of our detergents, shampoos and cosmetics, just to name a few.
Add to that growing list: PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), a group of man-made chemicals that includes PFOA, PFOS, GenX and numerous others. Many know PFAS by its more popular commercial name: Teflon. NYers grew even more familiar with PFAS contamination when the small town of Hoosick Falls, NY, discovered dangerously high levels of the toxic chemical in the town’s drinking water. The story of citizens taking control of the inexcusable position they were put in by polluting industries is all too familiar these days.
Why should we be concerned? PFASs are persistent organic pollutants that have been detected in humans and wildlife worldwide. From epidemiological studies of industrial workers and communities exposed to high levels of these substances, these “Forever Chemicals” accumulate in humans and have been linked to adverse health outcomes, including thyroid disease, high cholesterol levels, kidney cancer, testicular cancer, ulcerative colitis and developmental effects on unborn children. Evidence indicates PFASs affect the immune system, reducing the effectiveness of vaccines, particularly worrisome during the COVID-19 pandemic. Some advocates say there are no safe levels of PFAS exposure.
Since the 1950s, 3M and DuPont, the two chemical companies responsible for PFAS production, were increasingly aware of the health impacts of these chemicals but kept the information private even while they came up with more ways to use them. As recently as 2018, the Trump administration and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) attempted to suppress a study showing that PFASs were more dangerous than previously thought and that many of the contaminated sites are on military bases across the US.
The 2019 film Dark Waters tells the true story of Attorney Rob Bilott (portrayed by Mark Ruffalo) as he brings a case against DuPont after they knowingly contaminated a West Virginia town’s water supply with PFASs.
The Sierra Club Atlantic Chapter hosted an online screening of the film this past November, followed by an online panel discussion with Rob Bilott, Laureen Hackett (Hoosick Falls resident and activist), Mark Favors (military veteran, PFAS advocate and nurse on the frontlines of the coronavirus crisis), and Eve Gartner (Managing Attorney for the Toxic Exposure and Health program at Earthjustice). The full panel discussion can be found here.
As discussed on the panel, there’s often a general feeling of “What can I do?” Bilott stressed the need to stop as many of the continued areas of exposure to this chemical as possible, a “turn off the tap” of sorts.
The Atlantic Chapter is proud to have advocated for the successful passage of several pieces of legislation that are now law.
- Ban the use of firefighting foam containing perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl chemicals (PFAS) for training purposes, which avoids the unnecessary run-off of harmful chemicals into fresh water supplies through storm drains. This type of foam is often called aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF).
- Prohibit the incineration of AFFF and associated perfluorocarbon components. This law is specific to Cohoes, NY, where AFFF had been allowed to be incinerated at the Norlite Hazardous Waste facility, until local activism and pressure on decision makers ensured this legislation became law. We will continue to advocate for similar policies around the state. (Learn more about the Norlite facility at https://www.dec.ny.gov/chemical/121118.html)
- Ban the use of PFAS chemicals in food packaging. Who would have thought that enjoying some microwaved popcorn, pizza from your favorite pizzeria or even a store-made chocolate cake could expose one to PFASs? One of the things that has made PFAS chemicals so popular over the years is that they make materials more water- and grease-resistant, thus a very popular additive in food packaging. This most recent PFAS-related law in NYS is of extreme importance.
- Additionally, in 2019 the Atlantic Chapter advocated for the NYS Department of Health (DOH) to strengthen proposed regulations setting maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) for three chemicals — two PFAS chemicals: perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS), and also 1,4-dioxane. In the summer of 2020, Governor Cuomo announced a first-in-the-nation MCL for 1,4-dioxane (1 part per billion) as well as an MCL standard for PFOA and PFOS (10 parts per trillion) that is more protective than the federal standard of 70 ppt. (See the governor’s press release here)
As more and more communities (Rockland County and Mayville, NY, to name two) are discovering PFAS contamination in their drinking water supply — largely due to the new MCL requirement for water testing. The need to address this emerging contamination crisis is imperative. What we do now to protect ourselves will help determine the way this contamination is handled in the future by Governor Cuomo, state agencies and water utilities. It is urgent that the public not only be informed if these dangerous chemicals are in any public water supply, but it is also essential that the burden/cost of testing all rural communities and households with private wells not be placed on the public.
The lack of producer responsibility in the full life cycle of their products is certainly taking its toll. With so many chemicals introduced into the market each year, it is becoming increasingly apparent that the burden of safety needs to be addressed before communities are left with toxic chemicals in tainted water supplies.
The Sierra Club will continue to push for the strongest safeguards against these toxic forever chemicals. Here are a few things you can do to try and limit your household’s exposure to PFAS chemicals.
- Avoid items that say “nonstick” or “waterproof,” reduce the amount of fast food you consume, and check labels of beauty products and even dental floss for chemicals starting with “fluoro.”
- Contact the producers of brands that contain PFASs and ask them to stop using these ingredients. This will reduce the demand for their production.
- Push for stronger legislation from our federal and state governments to ban these forever chemicals and clean up polluted sites.
Additional Resources for Information on PFAS Chemicals
- Rob Bilott's book Exposure: Poisoned water, corporate greed, and one lawyer's 20-year battle against DuPont
- Read Mark Favors's testimony to the House Committee on Oversight and Reform from Nov 2019
- Loreen Hackett's Twitter page: https://twitter.com/pfoaprojectny1
- New York Times article about Loreen and her family
- Sierra Club handout on PFAS in drinking water: www.sierraclub.org/toxics/pfas
- Earthjustice PFAS page: https://earthjustice.org/features/breaking-down-toxic-pfas#
- CDC web page covering concerns that PFAS exposure will reduce effectiveness of vaccines: https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/pfas/health-effects/index.html
- Guardian story on PFAS and Covid: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/nov/17/chemicals-found-in-everyday-products-could-hinder-covid-19-vaccine
- Sierra Club “action” to new EPA: sc.org/pfas
- EWG timeline of the history of PFAS from 1950 to 2003: https://www.ewg.org/pfastimeline/
- EWG map of contaminated drinking water: https://www.ewg.org/interactive-maps/pfas_contamination/map/
- Sharon Lerner’s amazing series on PFAS: https://theintercept.com/collections/bad-chemistry/
- C-8 Medical Monitoring Program